• World
  • Columnist
  • Commodities
  • WORLD BUSINESS & ECONOMY
  • Executive Knowledge Series
  • Finance
  • Manufacturing
  • Markets
  • Risk & Governance
  • Small Business
  • Technology, Media & Innovation
  • Comments
  • Business AM WebTV
  • Login

Businessamlive
  • FRONTPAGE
  • FINANCE
    • AllAsset ManagementAuditBankingBondBudgetCapital MarketsC&I LeasingCurrencyDealDebt marketForexFund RaisingFundingGovernmentHedge FundsInsuranceInvestmentInvestorInvestor ServicesMergers & AcquistionsMoney marketMortgagePensionsPersonal financePonziQuantitative EasingshareTaxationTSAWealth Management
      Finance

      CBN gets new director of currency operations

      14 hrs

      Banking

      Q3’19: Banks’ NPLs moderate by N1.14trn

      December 5, 2019

      Finance

      Decline in FDI to persist in Nigeria, say experts

      December 5, 2019

      Banking

      Acess Bank donates to immigration service in Lagos

      December 5, 2019

  • MARKETS
  • ECONOMY
    • AllAfricaAgricAirportsAmericaAsiaAustraliaBreakthroughDealEuropeForeign InvestmentsforexGlobal marketGovernanceIMFMiddle EastNECANigeriaOutlookRich listSouth AfricaSport BusinessTradeU.KWest AfricaWorld Economic forum
      Frontpage

      Inflation may rise in coming months – LCCI

      14 hrs

      South Africa

      On South Africa GDP contraction 

      December 4, 2019

      Foreign Investments

      Countries seen rejecting foreign investments for national security, says UNCTAD report

      December 3, 2019

      Frontpage

      US in another trade war, vows to impose 100% fine on French goods 

      December 3, 2019

  • COMMODITIES
  • ENERGY
    • AllConferenceElectricityOil and GasPowerRenewable
      Energy

      Oil set for big weekly gains as OPEC+ agrees on deeper output cuts

      6 hrs

      Energy

      OPEC, allies cut oil output by 1.7mbpd

      December 5, 2019

      Frontpage

      US becomes net crude oil exporter, first time ever

      December 5, 2019

      Energy

      OPEC tackles energy poverty in Africa as oil nations convene in Vienna

      December 5, 2019

  • TECHNOLOGY
  • MANUFACTURING
  • ANALYSIS
    • Analysis

      Nigeria’s resilience against global risks

      December 3, 2019

      Analysis

      Getting the Board on board GRC implementation

      December 3, 2019

      Analysis

      How much money do you need?

      December 3, 2019

      Analysis

      On statement of changes in equity

      December 3, 2019

Project Syndicate by business a.m. Small Business

The IMF After Argentina

October 7, 2019515 views0 comments

By Kenneth Rogoff

 

 

CAMBRIDGE – In case you blinked, the Argentine government built up a pile of debt out of almost nothing with surprising speed, and then proceeded to default on it almost as quickly. Compared to the country’s slow-motion 2002 default, the latest crisis feels like 60-second Shakespeare. But in both cases, default was inevitable, because the country’s mix of debt, deficits, and monetary policy was unsustainable, and the political class was unable to make the necessary adjustments in time.

And in both cases, loans from the International Monetary Fund seemed only to postpone the inevitable, and, worse, to exacerbate the ultimate collapse. So, after the second debacle in Argentina in less than a generation, it’s high time to ask how to refocus the IMF’s mandate for dealing with emerging-market debt crises. How can the IMF be effective in helping countries regain access to private credit markets when any attempt to close unsustainable budget deficits is labeled austerity? The only answer is to increase substantially the resources of international aid agencies (the IMF is a lender). Unfortunately, there seems little appetite for that.

Why was the IMF willing to pour resources into a situation that – at least with the benefit of hindsight – could be resolved only through stronger fiscal adjustment (more austerity), a debt default, more foreign aid, or a mixture of all three?

The IMF’s difficulty in saying no to Argentina partly reflects an acrimonious history stemming from the failed loans from the late 1990s through 2001. It was also hard for the Fund to resist funding a big program in a world where countries can borrow at ultra-low interest rates from private markets. (China, too, has become a major source of funding in emerging markets, which might sound good in the abstract, but the lack of transparency makes Chinese loans fertile ground for corruption.)

But IMF staff know very well that countries with a history of serial default, such as Argentina and Venezuela, ride a slippery slope in debt markets. When Miguel Savastano, Carmen Reinhart, and I studied this phenomenon many years ago, we called it “debt intolerance.”

There is a case to be made that by pushing the IMF to go easy in its loan program, US President Donald Trump’s administration made Argentina’s latest economic calamity worse. After all, Argentine President Mauricio Macri’s father was a business partner and friend of Trump. But, whatever the truth of that argument, the Fund’s ever-weaker bargaining position probably has deeper roots.

Political support for necessary loan conditionality has been eroded by repeated attacks from the left, which does not accept that the IMF does not have scope to give outright grants. But while NGOs might cheer if the IMF were to convert its loans to grants, pretty soon the Fund’s coffers would be bare. This, too, might make some people happy, but it would be a disaster for global financial stability. Debt in many emerging markets today is at record levels, and the IMF remains the closest thing there is to a global lender of last resort. For all its limitations, the Fund has greater competency than any other organization to mitigate the costs of emerging-market debt crises, not least to the general population.

But the goal must be to prevent such crises from occurring – or recurring, as in Argentina’s case. Macri was elected in 2015 by a populace that had grown weary of the slow growth and high inflation that marked the last few years of former President Cristina Kirchner’s administration. Kirchner’s policies (and those of her husband, Néstor Kirchner, who preceded her) sharply expanded state intervention and control. Booming commodity export prices allowed the economy to continue growing, but when the cycle turned, it all fell apart.

Still, Macri inherited an economy where debt was not high (owing to the 2002 default), and the main fiscal problem was an unsustainable pension system. The normal prescription for an incoming administration would have been to take the pain of budget consolidation early on, and hope that the economy recovers well in advance of the next election. Instead, Macri decided to close the budget gap slowly, and use his political honeymoon to cut taxes and liberalize markets. Unfortunately, after Big Bang reforms, economic conditions tend to get worse before they get better, and it appears that Macri, facing an election later this month, will not be around to see that. Things have gotten so bad that Argentina has “reprofiled” (a form of default) even domestic-currency debt (which is more common than most people realize, as Reinhart and I showed in our 2009 book). It is a sad state of affairs.

It also demands an answer to a fundamental question: How can the IMF reconcile the need for a credible regime in which emerging markets can conduct necessary borrowing with demands for more aid and less austerity?

The short answer is that the IMF cannot do it alone. The only way to square the circle is with a huge increase in aid flows. But don’t expect either a Democratic or a Republican US administration to lead the charge. In the meantime, politicians should let the IMF do its job – helping to maintain global financial stability – and not force it to back unsustainable policy regimes.

 

____________________________________________________________________

Rogoff, a former chief economist of the IMF, is Professor of Economics and Public Policy at Harvard University.

About Post Author

<a href="https://www.businessamlive.com/byline/kenneth-rogoff/" rel="tag">Kenneth Rogoff</a>

See author's posts

Related posts:

Economist calls for creation of ministry for SMEs to boost economy
What Kind of Capitalism Do We Want?
Are Venture Capitalists Hopelessly Biased, or Deceptively Rational?
The economic potential of gender parity for Africa
SEC cancels bank signature verification for e-dividend exercise
The West’s Arrested Social Development
How the IMF Can Battle Gradual Irrelevance
A Green Industrialization Strategy for Africa  
The End of Neoliberalism and the Rebirth of History
The Monetarist Era is Over
Share on Facebook Tweet Email
PreviousOwerri’s Paris Heritage Hotel stands out among peers, boasts Benson
NextMilestones, prospects and urbanising Africa (1)

Leave a comment

- Cancel reply

MARKET DATA

Recent Posts

  • Oil set for big weekly gains as OPEC+ agrees on deeper output cuts
  • N675bn bribes paid to Nigerian public officials in 2019 – Report
  • OMSL denies involvement in alleged attack of NPA MD by hoodlums
  • Exhibitors over subscribe to Zenith Bank’s 2019 Lifestyle Fair
  • Inflation may rise in coming months – LCCI

World

Europe

EU businesses to cut investments in 2020, says EIB report

America

U.S. increases cost of visa application for Nigerians

Africa

Thatcher-Loving Nigeria Candidate Plans to Overhaul Economy

Africa

Ethiopia considers sale of minority stakes in telecoms, airline to foreign investors

Africa

AfDB scales up industrialization pace on the continent, delivers improved business access to finance, skills, energy

Frontpage posts

0

Policy easing in Nigeria seen in 2018 as more MPC members now pro-credit growth – Rencap

Frontpage November 10, 2017

1
2

AIF ’19 opens with greater expectations as it delivers on promises of maiden edition

Africa Investment Forum November 11, 2019

3

FPIs fret over Nigeria’s forex risk, mull fund repatriation

Frontpage August 12, 2019

4

Nigeria’s national budget grows 2,866% in 19yrs on worsening exchange rate, rising deficit

Frontpage November 10, 2017

5

GTB posts largest volume in deals worth N2.89bn, but stocks shed 1.3% on profit taking

Frontpage August 24, 2017

SUPPORT

  • Photo Gallery
  • Help Centre
  • About Us
  • Accessibility

LEGAL & PRIVACY

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy
  • Cookies
  • Copyright

SERVICES

  • Conferences & Events
  • Analysts Research
  • Advertising Rate
  • Ebooks

TOOLS

  • Portfolio
  • Newsletters
  • News feed
  • Currency Converter

SUBSCRIBE

Join us to get latest updates on business related news.

[mc4wp_form id="3076"]
  • ABOUT US
  • CONTACT US
  • CAREERS
  • TERMS & CONDITIONS
  • PRIVACY POLICY
Copyright 2017. All rights reserved. BusinessAMLive. A Businessnewscorp Member Company.