• World
  • Columnist
  • Commodities
  • WORLD BUSINESS & ECONOMY
  • Executive Knowledge Series
  • Finance
  • Manufacturing
  • Markets
  • Risk & Governance
  • Small Business
  • Technology, Media & Innovation
  • Comments
  • Business AM WebTV
  • Login

Businessamlive
  • FRONTPAGE
  • FINANCE
    • AllAsset ManagementAuditBankingBondBudgetCapital MarketsC&I LeasingCurrencyDealDebt marketForexFund RaisingFundingGovernmentHedge FundsInsuranceInvestmentInvestorInvestor ServicesMergers & AcquistionsMoney marketTreasury BillsMortgagePensionsPersonal financePonziQuantitative EasingshareTaxationTSAWealth Management
      Finance

      CBN says cryptocurrency ban in interest of Nigerians

      February 25, 2021

      Companies-in-Action

      Zenith Bank in strong operational performance as profit rises 10.4% to N230.56bn in FY20

      February 25, 2021

      Companies

      United Capital posts strong numbers as earnings rise 50% to N12.87bn in 2020

      February 23, 2021

      Finance

      CIBN revives mentorship initiative for bank workers

      February 20, 2021

  • MARKETS
  • ECONOMY
    • AllAfricaAgricAirportsAmericaAsiaAustraliaBreakthroughDealEuropeForeign InvestmentsforexGlobal marketGovernanceIMFMiddle EastNECANigeriaOutlookRich listSouth AfricaSport BusinessTradeU.KWest AfricaWorld Economic forum
      Insurance Business

      Enterprise risk management surges amid pandemic, RIMS reports

      February 25, 2021

      WORLD BUSINESS & ECONOMY

      Hyundai to recall 82,000 electric cars over battery malfunction

      February 25, 2021

      Frontpage

      Global health insurance premiums fall amid pandemic, says new report

      February 24, 2021

      Frontpage

      Insurance M&A record highest growth in Africa, Middle East in 2020

      February 23, 2021

  • COMMODITIES
  • ENERGY
    • AllConferenceElectricityOil and GasPowerRenewable
      Oil and Gas

      REA delivers 100kW hybrid solar mini grid to Edo community

      February 25, 2021

      Oil and Gas

      OPL 310: LEKOIL engages Optimum Petroleum over CRSA agreement

      February 25, 2021

      Frontpage

      Nigeria still losing 200,000bpd crude daily as NNPC enlists army’s intervention

      February 25, 2021

      Frontpage

      Nigeria to sell 170MW electricity capacity to Togo from Calabar plant

      February 24, 2021

  • TECHNOLOGY
  • MANUFACTURING
  • ANALYSIS
    • Analyst Insight

      Incorporating three lines of defence in data privacy schemes

      < 1 min

      Analyst Insight

      Coronation MB analysts project sharp rates rise after Nigeria recession exit

      February 25, 2021

      Analyst Insight

      How NITDA can further foster data protection compliance in Nigeria

      February 22, 2021

      Analyst Insight

      Do we need more start-ups in insurance?

      February 16, 2021

Knowledge@Wharton

Will Parler Prevail in Its Antitrust Case Against Amazon?

January 25, 2021313 views0 comments

Far-right social media network Parler is unlikely to win its antitrust lawsuit against Amazon because it will be difficult to prove that the tech giant booted the platform off its server for competitive reasons, according to Wharton professor Herbert Hovenkamp.

Will Parler Prevail in Its Antitrust Case Against Amazon?

Parler, which was founded in 2018 and boasts more than 4 million users, was effectively shut down on January 10 after Amazon removed the network from its web-hosting service. Apple and Google also dropped Parler from its app stores, the two largest on the internet. The moves came after public outcry that the conservative network was instrumental in helping users foment a January 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol.

Parler’s complaint, filed on January 11 in federal court, alleges antitrust violation, breach of contract and interference with the company’s business relationships with users. It wants a temporary restraining order against Amazon to reinstate the service.

“I don’t think that the antitrust complaint is going to fly for a couple of reasons,” Hovenkamp said during an interview on the Wharton Business Daily radio show on SiriusXM. (Listen to the podcast at the top of this page.)

Hovenkamp, an antitrust expert who holds a joint appointment as a University of Pennsylvania law professor and Wharton professor of legal studies and business ethics, said the complaint is based on the notion that Amazon and Twitter conspired to eliminate Parler as competition for Twitter, which is also hosted on Amazon Web Services.

“The problem is the complaint simply doesn’t allege facts that tend to show that, and the federal courts require that these complaints be fairly specific,” he said. “You can’t just kind of make an atmospheric claim that there is a conspiracy. You really have to put some facts into it, and there really aren’t any facts here that would support that kind of conspiracy claim.”

Hovenkamp added that antitrust laws typically do not cover “political terminations.” Parler would have to prove that Amazon’s decision to eliminate political speech was motivated by profit, yet Amazon said it repeatedly warned the network about its failure to identify and remove threatening content.

In its response filed on January 12, Amazon said the case is without merit and asked the court to dismiss it.

“This case is not about suppressing speech or stifling viewpoints. It is not about a conspiracy to restrain trade,” Amazon said in the court document. “Instead, this case is about Parler’s demonstrated unwillingness and inability to remove … content that threatens the public safety, such as by inciting and planning the rape, torture, and assassination of named public officials and private citizens.”

Lastly, Hovenkamp said, Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act provides immunity for information content providers that block offensive material.

“If Amazon is acting under the Communications Decency Act to shut down Parler, then the conduct is probably not breachable under the antitrust law in any event,” he noted.

A Reckoning for Social Media?

Longstanding questions about government regulation of social media and tech companies are taking center stage with Parler’s removal from Amazon Web Services and the decision by Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and other social media platforms to suspend President Donald Trump’s account. This could be a year of reckoning for these companies, Hovenkamp said, but the conversations about content are separate from the legal issues surrounding antitrust.

“There’s a question about whether hosting services use this power in a reasonable way. Are they actually using it in order to shut down improper speech? I don’t think there’s too much question that threats to hang the vice president are improper,” he said. “But are they also using it in a way simply to dismiss conservative voices? All of them, including Amazon, vigorously deny that they’re going after conservative voices as such.”

Any congressional investigation into the actions of Amazon or Twitter will probably just reveal what is already known: The companies took action after Parler’s users exhorted citizens to violence. “Hang Mike Pence” was trending on Twitter late last week; the phrase had been tweeted more than 14,000 times before the company put a stop to it.

“The most you can get out of this investigation is that Amazon shut down threats to hang the vice president or kill [House Speaker] Nancy Pelosi or to take over government buildings by force or violence,” Hovenkamp said. “If that’s the most that they’re going to be able to get, then that’s not going to go very far.”

Share on Facebook Tweet Email
PreviousWhy Universal Basic Income Should Be President Biden’s Top Priority
NextNigeria’s electricity DisCos create imbalance costing N20.5bn in 3 weeks  

Leave a comment

- Cancel reply

MARKET DATA

Market Videos

Recent Posts

  • Africa and the decade of COVID-19 (5)
  • Reworking Public Sector: AI and public service delivery
  • Incorporating three lines of defence in data privacy schemes
  • How India Could Win Its COVID Vaccination Race
  • Nigeria missing out on 298m jobs, $7.6trn beach-driven T&T market

World

Africa

Buhari, Okonjo-Iweala congratulate Adesina over reelection as AfDB President

Europe

EU businesses to cut investments in 2020, says EIB report

America

U.S. increases cost of visa application for Nigerians

Africa

Thatcher-Loving Nigeria Candidate Plans to Overhaul Economy

Africa

AfDB scales up industrialization pace on the continent, delivers improved business access to finance, skills, energy

Frontpage posts

0

Nigeria equities open week bearish as index goes red

Frontpage November 17, 2020

1
2

NNPC committed to end fuel importation, names firms to finance refineries rehabilitation in June

Frontpage May 6, 2018

3

Investors wary of US response to virus as stock indexes slump at open

Equities March 11, 2020

4

Point of sale transactions record 33% y/y increase, hits N634bn in Q1 2019

Frontpage August 7, 2019

5

COVID-19: PFAs under pressure to release pension fund

Frontpage April 27, 2020

SUPPORT

  • Photo Gallery
  • Help Centre
  • About Us
  • Accessibility

LEGAL & PRIVACY

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy
  • Cookies
  • Copyright

SERVICES

  • Conferences & Events
  • Analysts Research
  • Advertising Rate
  • Ebooks

TOOLS

  • Portfolio
  • Newsletters
  • News feed
  • Currency Converter

SUBSCRIBE

Join us to get latest updates on business related news.

[mc4wp_form id="3076"]
  • ABOUT US
  • CONTACT US
  • CAREERS
  • TERMS & CONDITIONS
  • PRIVACY POLICY
Copyright 2017. All rights reserved. BusinessAMLive. A Businessnewscorp Member Company.