• World
  • Columnist
  • Commodities
  • WORLD BUSINESS & ECONOMY
  • Executive Knowledge Series
  • Finance
  • Manufacturing
  • Markets
  • Risk & Governance
  • Small Business
  • Technology, Media & Innovation
  • Comments
  • Business AM WebTV
  • Login

Businessamlive
  • FRONTPAGE
  • FINANCE
    • AllAsset ManagementAuditBankingBondBudgetCapital MarketsC&I LeasingCurrencyDealDebt marketForexFund RaisingFundingGovernmentHedge FundsInsuranceInvestmentInvestorInvestor ServicesMergers & AcquistionsMoney marketTreasury BillsMortgagePensionsPersonal financePonziQuantitative EasingshareTaxationTSAWealth Management
      Finance

      Stringent regulations, business environment forced Stanbic IBTC out of BDC business

      7 hrs

      Finance

      Cautious equities trading see gains in Flour Mills, Mobil, Wapco push market cap to ₦21.09trn

      8 hrs

      Finance

      CBN issues guidelines for QR codes operation in Nigeria

      8 hrs

      Finance

      Global Equities: Positive sentiment buoys global markets’ performance on vaccine rollout, Biden confirmation

      January 13, 2021

  • MARKETS
  • ECONOMY
    • AllAfricaAgricAirportsAmericaAsiaAustraliaBreakthroughDealEuropeForeign InvestmentsforexGlobal marketGovernanceIMFMiddle EastNECANigeriaOutlookRich listSouth AfricaSport BusinessTradeU.KWest AfricaWorld Economic forum
      Frontpage

      Moody’s sees negative 2021 outlook for sub-Saharan Africa, with severe economic challenges

      7 hrs

      Commodities

      Metals make sluggish gains on LME, SHFE, as investors anticipate US stimulus

      7 hrs

      WORLD BUSINESS & ECONOMY

      Smart home market profits to reach $176bn in 2025, rising by 127%  

      7 hrs

      Technology

      Zoom to float $1.5bn in fresh capital issue, approaches SEC

      8 hrs

  • COMMODITIES
  • ENERGY
    • AllConferenceElectricityOil and GasPowerRenewable
      Frontpage

      NNPC moves to rehabilitate downstream infrastructure, openscontract bids

      7 hrs

      Companies

      Ardova enters acquisition talks with Enyo as part of expansion drive  

      7 hrs

      Oil and Gas

      NNPC reaffirms commitment to OPEC+ agreement   

      8 hrs

      Imo

      FIRST E&P faces CSR headwinds in Bayelsacommunities, ahead OMLs 83, 85 production start

      8 hrs

  • TECHNOLOGY
  • MANUFACTURING
  • ANALYSIS
    • Analyst Insight

      Data privacy maturity model in organisations

      January 11, 2021

      Analyst Insight

      Stocks set for more record highs

      January 11, 2021

      Analyst Insight

      2021: Time for Nigeria to move into higher gear?

      January 11, 2021

      Analyst Insight

      The trouble with commissions

      January 5, 2021

Insead Knowledge

Banks are still thinking short-term

June 19, 20171.1K views0 comments

ECONOMICS & FINANCE

Boris Liedtke, Distinguished Executive Fellow, INSEAD Emerging Markets Institute and S. David Young, INSEAD Professor of Accounting and Control


A single-minded focus on the bottom line can destroy value.

Among the multiple organisational failures that led to the global financial crisis, one is fairly well buried in the debate. Much was made of the incentives that skewed short-term risk taking but behind these misguided incentives was a single-minded focus on the bottom line.

Broadly speaking, large banks failed to properly define and assess value, making it difficult for managers to achieve long-term success. For example, the singular profit-as-incentive strategy to motivate employees to meet goals meant value was, in fact, destroyed. According to “Blue Line Management: What Managing for Value Really Means”, a concept and book (The Blue Line Imperative) developed by INSEAD Professors David Young and Kevin Kaiser, business decisions can only ever create value or destroy it.

Value destruction, especially when allowed to happen over extended periods, can wreak havoc, as the global financial crisis showed. This has implications far beyond staff, investors and clients and still challenges the financial industry today.

Banks are still going wrong

Many financial institutions are currently plagued with significant budget and cost problems. This is largely the result of increasing costs due to growing regulatory compliance and mushrooming IT expenses.

The IT budget makes up a substantial part of direct and indirect costs and hence is the target of any meaningful cost-reduction exercise. A large bulk of an IT budget is allocated towards run-the-bank (RTB) IT expenses.This is a cost that needs to be spent to simply keep the existing technology platform running. Typical items here are IT staff, market data, hardware amortisation, software and vendor costs, and sometimes external consultants. A substantially smaller part of the budget is the change-the-bank (CTB) budget. These are expenses the bank incurs to change its existing platforms and are mainly driven by regulatory change, product change, system enhancements and client experience enhancements.

As banks have become increasingly cost conscious, overall IT budgets have come under increased scrutiny. Reducing RTB costs can be very difficult. Short of reducing business complexity or investing in CTB to implement system enhancements, the bank, in the short and medium term, must fund these costs completely. This leaves cuts in CTB budgets as the only realistic option. But even these cuts can be exceedingly difficult to implement in practice. Departments within the bank often engage in fierce disputes to improve their technology platforms. The front office is usually most interested in enhancements to client interface and user experience. However, regulatory and product changes tend to take priority within the organisation to ensure that legal, compliance, tax and reputational issues are kept to a minimum. The required CTB budget allocation in these areas simply takes priority over modifications the sales or front office teams would like to see.

Under these conditions, how can the IT project managers obtain approval for their annual budgets to please internal clients – for example, the front office – to still find some CTB budget to enhance client experience when RTB and CTB expenditures focused on regulatory change are eating up the IT budget? One way he or she could do this is to become creative and shift costs from the profit and loss statement (P&L) to the balance sheet.

Typically, the Finance department would allow certain projects to be classified as long-term enhancements to the IT platform and hence the bulk of associated costs for these enhancements are classified as assets instead of  booked as expenses on the income statement. The assets are eventually expensed through the amortisation process, but only gradually, typically over three years. To track this, an internal cost centre is created, against which all costs associated are booked and later capitalised.

Pizza on the balance sheet

What does this look like in practice? Late one night, as the IT project team exceeds their normal working hours, they are entitled to dinner at the company’s expense. They call for pizza delivery as they continue working and, of course, the pizza cost becomes part of the IT project costs, booked against the project IT cost centre. When the project is completed, the original pizza costs form part of the overall IT enhancement asset capitalised on the balance sheet, ready to be written off over the next three years. In one case we know of, the balance sheet included US$3 million of such costs. Although the notion of calling US$3 million in takeaways an asset seems absurd, it does allow the bank to stay within its CTB budget and also offers the additional benefits of boosting reported profits in the short term. The question of value or value creation is seldom asked in this scenario.

The costs of pizza as part of a project are, of course, minor but this example illustrates the extent and absurdity that this results in. And if this is done with pizza, what else do banks have on their balance sheet that from a common-sense point of view should have been written off?

This behaviour may seem relatively harmless for a bank with a big balance sheet but it demonstrates a certain mind-set that is clearly contrary to value creation. To further illustrate the seriousness of a lack of value-driven decision making in the financial sector, we will turn towards a more serious topic – corporate mergers and disposals – in our article next month.


S. David Young is a Professor of Accounting & Control at INSEAD. He is a co-author of The Blue Line Imperative.

Boris Liedtke is a Distinguished Executive Fellow in the INSEAD Emerging Markets Institute.


This article is republished courtesy of http://knowledge.insead.edu. Copyright INSEAD 2017.

Share on Facebook Tweet Email
TagsBanks ECONOMICS & FINANCE Insead
PreviousBEDC to publish power availability schedules to customers
NextTalent management for the age of career disruption

Leave a comment

- Cancel reply

MARKET DATA

Market Videos

Recent Posts

  • Nigeria’s railway e-ticketing platform launch set for next week
  • Stringent regulations, business environment forced Stanbic IBTC out of BDC business
  • Copper faces downturn in H2 of 2021, analysts predict
  • NNPC moves to rehabilitate downstream infrastructure, openscontract bids
  • Moody’s sees negative 2021 outlook for sub-Saharan Africa, with severe economic challenges

World

Africa

Buhari, Okonjo-Iweala congratulate Adesina over reelection as AfDB President

Europe

EU businesses to cut investments in 2020, says EIB report

America

U.S. increases cost of visa application for Nigerians

Africa

Thatcher-Loving Nigeria Candidate Plans to Overhaul Economy

Africa

AfDB scales up industrialization pace on the continent, delivers improved business access to finance, skills, energy

Frontpage posts

0

We’ll list on NSE before July, says MTN as Nigeria revenue hits N965bn

Frontpage March 7, 2019

1
2

Rivers economy: Wike lists Amaechi’s N131.28bn monorail, hospital, model schools, others as white elephant projects

Frontpage September 28, 2020

3

Oil prices dip on signs of slowing U.S. demand, economic concerns

Frontpage July 4, 2019

4

Fiscal crisis widens as FG’s revenue plunges in Q1

Frontpage July 22, 2020

5

Coronavirus: FG to review budget, adopt new oil benchmark

Frontpage March 10, 2020

SUPPORT

  • Photo Gallery
  • Help Centre
  • About Us
  • Accessibility

LEGAL & PRIVACY

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy
  • Cookies
  • Copyright

SERVICES

  • Conferences & Events
  • Analysts Research
  • Advertising Rate
  • Ebooks

TOOLS

  • Portfolio
  • Newsletters
  • News feed
  • Currency Converter

SUBSCRIBE

Join us to get latest updates on business related news.

[mc4wp_form id="3076"]
  • ABOUT US
  • CONTACT US
  • CAREERS
  • TERMS & CONDITIONS
  • PRIVACY POLICY
Copyright 2017. All rights reserved. BusinessAMLive. A Businessnewscorp Member Company.