• World
  • Columnist
  • Commodities
  • WORLD BUSINESS & ECONOMY
  • Executive Knowledge Series
  • Finance
  • Manufacturing
  • Markets
  • Risk & Governance
  • Small Business
  • Technology, Media & Innovation
  • Comments
  • Business AM WebTV
  • Login

Businessamlive
  • FRONTPAGE
  • FINANCE
    • AllAsset ManagementAuditBankingBondBudgetCapital MarketsC&I LeasingCurrencyDealDebt marketForexFund RaisingFundingGovernmentHedge FundsInsuranceInvestmentInvestorInvestor ServicesMergers & AcquistionsMoney marketTreasury BillsMortgagePensionsPersonal financePonziQuantitative EasingshareTaxationTSAWealth Management
      Finance

      Nigeria, Africa remittances on target as Wari, Lycaremit sign partnership

      January 21, 2021

      Companies

      Total Nigeria, Mixta, Valency, list new CPs on FMDQ platform to enhance financial markets development

      January 19, 2021

      Finance

      Amidst N32.22trn public debt, analysts say Nigeria’s external debt service manageable

      January 19, 2021

      Finance

      Stringent regulations, business environment forced Stanbic IBTC out of BDC business

      January 15, 2021

  • MARKETS
  • ECONOMY
    • AllAfricaAgricAirportsAmericaAsiaAustraliaBreakthroughDealEuropeForeign InvestmentsforexGlobal marketGovernanceIMFMiddle EastNECANigeriaOutlookRich listSouth AfricaSport BusinessTradeU.KWest AfricaWorld Economic forum
      Markets

      Nairobi Stock Exchange pushes expansion plans with more listings in 2021, says CEO

      January 23, 2021

      Africa Investment Forum

      Africa’s $60bn losses in illicit capital flows due to multinationals’ tax avoidance, says AfDB Adesina

      January 22, 2021

      Frontpage

      Covid-19 vaccine: Nigeria, 54 others to benefit from African Union’s 270m doses

      January 21, 2021

      Finance

      Nigeria, Africa remittances on target as Wari, Lycaremit sign partnership

      January 21, 2021

  • COMMODITIES
  • ENERGY
    • AllConferenceElectricityOil and GasPowerRenewable
      Companies

      Appeal Court suspends order against shutting of SEPLAT headoffice

      January 23, 2021

      Frontpage

      OPEC welcomes push for electric vehicles, but says fossil fuel remains strong

      January 21, 2021

      National: Governance, Policy & Politics

      Nigeria ramps up domestic LPG consumption above 1MMT, says PPPRA

      January 20, 2021

      Companies

      TIPP Oil, German lubricant maker, targets 2021 Nigeria launch with eco-friendly scheme  

      January 19, 2021

  • TECHNOLOGY
  • MANUFACTURING
  • ANALYSIS
    • Analyst Insight

      CBN meeting and NSE in focus

      January 18, 2021

      Analyst Insight

      Once again, fiscal stimulus takes centre stage

      January 18, 2021

      Analyst Insight

      Organisations must learn from the WhatsApp story  

      January 18, 2021

      Analyst Insight

      Data privacy maturity model in organisations

      January 11, 2021

Analyst Insight

The trouble with commissions

January 5, 2021320 views0 comments

By Charlie Wilmerding

 

Commissions have been a fact of life for as long as there have been insurance brokers, but should they be? While businesses have always sought to contain or reduce their insurance- and risk-related expenses, insurance brokers have traditionally been paid a percentage of their clients’ premiums in the form of a commission. The more the client pays for their insurance, the more the broker makes. Brokers and agents have tried to position themselves as ‘independent’ and ‘trusted advisors,’ but in the end they are neither.

I don’t mean to suggest that all agents and brokers are bad people. In fact, there are many good, ethical people in the business. It’s not the people that are the problem. The problem is the business and its compensation structure.

The conflict of interest that underlies commission plagues the brokerage business at every step of the insurance-buying process, leaving customers without the leverage and power they deserve. As long as agents and brokers tie their compensation to insurance transactions, they risk becoming irrelevant as their clients seek alternatives to buying insurance that give them confidence they have been given a fair shake in the process.

Clients are looking for resources and information, objective advice and solutions, and access to insurance markets without having to worry about any backroom commission schemes that ultimately breed distrust. Without commission, a conversation about buying higher limits of insurance takes on a different and more productive tone – the broker doesn’t get paid any more or less as a result of their client’s objectively informed decision.

Insurance buyers aren’t the only ones affected by this conflict of interest. Insurance carriers are challenged by commission as well. As a rule, commissions are insurers’ second largest expense behind paid losses. Though carriers are most concerned with their net premiums written, they would prefer to have that net premium delivered directly to their insureds without commission inflating and distorting the actual risk transfer premium.

In Chubb’s 2016 annual report, Chairman and CEO Evan Greenberg called out brokers for some “abusive behavior” involving commission: “Cloaked in the mantra of ‘customer best interest’ or ‘treating customers fairly,’ they seek the cheapest price and broadest coverage at commission terms that, by any measure, are excessive,” Greenberg said.

As this statement implies, broker commissions have been impacting industry decisions forever for the sole benefit of one party in the insurance transaction: the broker. It’s time to pull back the curtain and embrace a different, fairer compensation model that gives the customer not only complete transparency, but also the power and leverage they deserve in what has traditionally been an opaque industry.

One way to put control back into clients’ hands is to eliminate commissions entirely and move to a fee-for-service model. When clients pay their broker a flat fee for the services they receive instead of a commission based on the amount of premium they pay, they’re empowered to make the right decisions for their business and themselves about their insurance coverage. Moving to a fee-based model allows brokers to truly become trusted advisors, which is essential for the survival of the brokerage business.

Importantly, fee-based still doesn’t mean ‘one size fits all.’ Charging fees allows brokers to customize a service plan for each client. At Altus, we’ve created a proprietary model using 10 service-based criteria that generate fees tailored to each client’s unique needs. Using this method, we significantly reduce our clients’ brokerage expenses in both the short and long term. In doing so, we are freed to aggressively seek out the best terms, conditions and pricing from underwriters without worrying if a lower premium will negatively impact our revenue.

As agents and brokers, we should strive to be considered vital partners who can help our clients navigate the often mysterious and confusing world of insurance while aligning our interests with theirs as best we can.

Let’s stop living under the assumption that the commission model works for everyone. The truth is it doesn’t work for anyone – except the broker. Let’s eliminate the conflict of interest so we can be the trusted advisors and advocates that clients want, need and value.

 

______________________________________________________________________________

Charlie Wilmerding is the founder and CEO of Altus Partners, which he started in 1997 to change the way that property & casualty insurance is bought and managed.

Share on Facebook Tweet Email
PreviousOwerri should have dry port or inland container depot – CEO, CRISP
NextNigeria: Agriculture without TECHNOLOGY =

Leave a comment

- Cancel reply

MARKET DATA

Market Videos

Recent Posts

  • Appeal Court suspends order against shutting of SEPLAT headoffice
  • Eko Atlantic City to utilise local content for economic diversification in Nigeria
  • Nairobi Stock Exchange pushes expansion plans with more listings in 2021, says CEO
  • Africa’s $60bn losses in illicit capital flows due to multinationals’ tax avoidance, says AfDB Adesina
  • Nigeria equities go bearish on selloffs in DangCem, AXA Mansard, UBA

World

Africa

Buhari, Okonjo-Iweala congratulate Adesina over reelection as AfDB President

Europe

EU businesses to cut investments in 2020, says EIB report

America

U.S. increases cost of visa application for Nigerians

Africa

Thatcher-Loving Nigeria Candidate Plans to Overhaul Economy

Africa

AfDB scales up industrialization pace on the continent, delivers improved business access to finance, skills, energy

Frontpage posts

0

CBN registers 8 cash-in-transit, 2 currency processing firms

Frontpage April 30, 2019

1
2

DisCos Q1 revenue collection hits N116.9bn

Frontpage September 13, 2019

3

Chinese outnumber Americans on rich list for first time ever

Frontpage October 21, 2019

4

SME’s reel from lack of legislation on crowdfunding in securities market

Frontpage August 13, 2018

5

Markets ready for FG’s N565bn Q1 borrowing plan

Frontpage January 20, 2020

SUPPORT

  • Photo Gallery
  • Help Centre
  • About Us
  • Accessibility

LEGAL & PRIVACY

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy
  • Cookies
  • Copyright

SERVICES

  • Conferences & Events
  • Analysts Research
  • Advertising Rate
  • Ebooks

TOOLS

  • Portfolio
  • Newsletters
  • News feed
  • Currency Converter

SUBSCRIBE

Join us to get latest updates on business related news.

[mc4wp_form id="3076"]
  • ABOUT US
  • CONTACT US
  • CAREERS
  • TERMS & CONDITIONS
  • PRIVACY POLICY
Copyright 2017. All rights reserved. BusinessAMLive. A Businessnewscorp Member Company.